Handbook – Practical procedures for subjective testing 2011
Foreword
Table of Contents
Section 1 – General
1.0 General
1.1 Comments on subjective methods used in the laboratory
1.2 Utilization of the outcome of experiments
1.3 ITU-T Recommendations
1.4 The continuing need for subjective tests
1.5 Laboratory tests versus field tests
1.6 Recommended methods
1.6.1 Conversational opinion tests
1.6.2 Listening opinion tests
1.6.3 Interview and survey tests
1.6.4 Other subjective test methods
Section 2 – Test purpose
2.0 Introduction
2.1 Qualification
2.2 Selection
2.3 Characterization
2.4 Verification
2.5 Research
2.6 Others
Section 3 – Experimental designs
3.0 Introduction
3.1 Steps to designing a subjective test
3.2 Design elements and design principles
3.2.1 Sources of variability (languages, talkers, speech material, subjects, ...)
3.2.2 Factors - random or fixed effects
3.3 Types of test designs
3.3.1 Factorial design
3.3.2 Balanced blocks experimental design
3.3.3 Latin Square and related designs
3.3.4 Graeco-Latin Square design
3.3.5 Nested design
3.3.6 Other designs
3.4 Scales
3.4.1 Nominal scale
3.4.2 Ordinal scale
3.4.3 Interval scale
3.4.4 Ratio scale
Section 4 – Conversational opinion tests
4.0 Introduction
4.1 Test facilities
4.2 Test design
4.3 Conversation task
4.4 Test procedure
4.4.1 Selection of test subjects
4.4.2 Subjective evaluation criteria and opinion scales
4.4.3 Example instructions to subjects of the conversational test
4.4.4 Data collection
4.4.5 Data analysis and report of results
Section 5 – Listening opinion tests
5.0 Introduction
5.1 Database material
5.1.1 Speech
5.1.2 Noise database
5.1.3 Processing for addition of noise and speech
5.2 Reference systems
5.2.1 Intermediate reference system
5.2.2 Modified Intermediate Reference System
5.2.3 Flat filtering systems
5.2.4 Other filtering systems
5.3 Collection of source material
5.3.1 Recording environment
5.3.2 Recording system
5.3.3 Control of the speech/music data base
5.3.4 Processing of the speech files
5.3.5 Source/Processed speech file naming convention
5.4 Listening test procedure
5.4.1 Listening environment
5.4.2 Listening system
5.4.3 Listening level
5.4.4 Eligibility of subjects
5.4.5 Subjective evaluation criteria and Opinion scales
5.4.6 Equivalence of opinion scales between languages
5.4.7 Category judgement
5.4.8 Instructions to subjects
Section 6 – Statistical analysis and reporting of results
6.0 Introduction
6.1 Basic concepts of statistics
6.1.1 General principles of statistics
6.1.2 Definitions
6.1.3 Application in subjective tests
6.2 Student t-tests
6.2.1 Advantages and disadvantages
6.2.2 Definitions
6.3 Analysis of Variance
6.3.1 Purpose and underlying assumptions
6.3.2 Analysis
6.3.3 Post hoc comparison of means
Section 7 – Experimental design for speech coder evaluations (controlling sources of error)
7.0 Introduction
7.1 Source material factors (recording procedures, talker factors)
7.2 Laboratory factors
7.3 Language factors
7.4 Listener factors (selection and sampling, instructions and training)
7.5 Time/order factors, balance factors (generation of randomization), test context
7.6 Sequences/sessions duration
7.7 Presentation of results
7.7.1 Analysis tools
7.7.2 Data collection
7.7.3 GAL
Section 8 – Examples of Test plans/Results on coders
Annex A – Processing principles (Software Tool Library)
A.1 Scope
A.2 History
A.3 Motivation
A.4 Software tools to emulate transmission chains
A.5 Software tools to process references for subjective tests
A.6 Software tool for ITU-T speech and audio codecs specification and objective performance assessment
A.7 Using the STL for implementing processing associated with a test design
Annex B – Relationship between subjective and objective test methods
B.1 Recommendation ITU-T P.862
B.2 Perceptually Weighted Misclassification Counting
Appendix 1 – Misclassified active frame replacement procedure
Bibliography